More states are pondering the legislative bandwagon mandating breast ultrasound screening for women with heterogeneous or dense breasts. While lawmakers debate the merits of ultrasound screening, some breast imagers are transitioning from handheld ultrasound screening to automated ultrasound systems to image women with heterogeneous or dense breasts.
Legislation spurs demand
Jefferson Radiology in Hartford, Conn., launched a breast ultrasound screening program in 2005, encountering a lukewarm reception. "Anecdotally, 5 to 10 percent of women wanted ultrasound screening prior to 2009," recalls Jinnah A. Phillips, MD, director of breast imaging.
However, in October 2009, Connecticut became the first state to pass breast density legislation, which requires providers to notify women if their mammogram reveals dense breast tissue. It also requires insurers to cover adjunctive testing, such as screening ultrasound or MRI for these women.
"After the law passed, we saw overwhelming demand," says Phillips. Within a few months of its passage, the practice had a backlog of more than 500 patients requesting ultrasound screenings. At that point, Jefferson Radiology added automated breast ultrasound screening to its handheld ultrasound screening program. To keep up with increasing demand, the practice would have had to eliminate other ultrasound studies. The automated breast ultrasound system provides the throughput to image 25 to 30 patients daily, says Phillips.
The automated screening model can succeed without legislation and reimbursement. Susan J. Ward, MD, radiologist with Renown Breast Health Center in Reno, Nev., decided to integrate automated ultrasound into practice after reviewing a study published in the European Journal of Radiology in March 2008, which showed breast ultrasound screening doubled the cancer detection rate among women with dense breasts compared with mammography.
In October 2010, the center installed an automated system while seeking to educate women and referring physicians about breast density and screening ultrasound. The practice modified its screening mammography patient letter to add information about breast density.
|Dense Breast Legislative Update|
|Connecticut: Breast Density Inform law and insurance coverage for supplemental breast ultrasound screening as an adjunct to mammography (October 2009)
Illinois: Insurance coverage for whole breast ultrasound screening as an adjunct to mammography (March 2009)
Texas: Breast Density Inform law * (September 2011)
Florida, New York: Pending Breast Density Inform * legislation
*Breast Density Inform legislation requires providers to notify women of heterogeneous or dense breast tissue, but does not require payors to reimburse for the study.
"Patients and referring physicians were confused at first," admits Ward. "In the last six months, medical and popular literature have addressed the topic, and we've added posters and pamphlets. Now, women understand the importance of screening ultrasound."
The effort led to a spike in ultrasound volume. In Nevada, where women pay out of pocket for the study, the practice has scanned 110 women since formally launching the program in November 2010. However, most studies were requested in the last six months.
Ward estimates that half of the 10,000 mammograms she reads annually indicate heterogeneous or dense breast tissue. "I've been frustrated for a long time because you can only see so much on the mammograms in these cases." The challenge has been exacerbated by increasing constraints on screening MRI. Beginning in 2010, some payors started re-categorizing breast MRI as experimental for anyone with less than a 25 percent risk of breast cancer and tightened reimbursement parameters.
Ultrasound can provide another screening option for women with dense or heterogenous breast tissue.
Marla R. Lander, MD, a breast radiologist at Desert Comprehensive Breast Center in Palm Springs, Calif., participated in a three-year study that provided 3D ultrasound to women with breast density greater than 50 percent. "About 98 percent of women jumped on the screening opportunity when offered," she says.
Plus, patients continue to return for ultrasound screenings. "Women like ultrasound because it is more comfortable [than mammography], and our discovery rate of cancer is higher. Women feel more secure with the additional study and referring physicians appreciate the supplementary