Software helps CTA identify lesions, but fails to ID highest risk plaque

Twitter icon
Facebook icon
LinkedIn icon
e-mail icon
Google icon

Using plaque analysis software, researchers found that CT angiography (CTA) reliably identified and quantified coronary atherosclerotic plaques when compared with intravascular ultrasound. The software, however, had limited reliability to differentiate the composition of noncalcified plaques.

Once plaques are detected, cardiologists may want to differentiate them between calcified (stable) and noncalcified (unstable and more prone to rupture). Intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) is the gold standard to visualize coronary artery walls, but it is expensive and not suited for routine risk stratification.

Junyan Sun, MD, and colleagues from radiology and cardiology at Beijing An Zhen Hospital in China sought to determine how reliably 64-slice CTA could identify, classify, and quantify coronary plaques compared with IVUS. They published the study in the March issue of the American Journal of Roentgenology.

The researchers evaluated 26 patients with CT (Aquilion 64, Toshiba America Medical Systems) and IVUS (Eagle Eye, Volcano). Eleven patients had acute coronary syndrome and 15 patients had stable angina. All patients had abnormal ECG results.

The plaque analysis software (Sure Plaque, Toshiba) displayed different CT density ranges (Hounsfield units)—hypothesized to represent different components of plaque—with various colors.

  • Red represented lipid composition (range, –100 to 29 HU)
  • Blue represented fibrous composition (range, 30-189 HU)
  • Yellow represented calcification (range, 350-1,000 HU)
  • Green represented lumen (range, 190-349 HU), and
  • Luteous represented vessel wall (range, 30-189 HU), same range as for fibrous composition.

The preset HU ranges could be manually altered. Researchers classified plaques displayed as red or green as noncalcified, and yellow as calcified without considering the calcified size.

Coronary artery cross section of 48-year-old man obtained by intravascular ultrasound indicates fibrous area (hyperechoic, thick arrow) and lipid-rich area (hypoechoic, thin arrow). (Source: All images from American Roentgen Ray Society)  
Cross-sectional view of same noncalcified plaque as above obtained by CT and analyzed with plaque software. Red area indicates lipid-rich area (hypodensity, thin arrow) and blue area indicates fibrous area (hyperdensity, thick straight arrow). Green indicates contrast-enhanced vessel lumen (curved arrow).  

Of 40 coronary arteries, 247 of 263 segments were imaged and analyzed by both CTA and IVUS. Sixteen segments were ruled out because of poor CT image quality.

Compared with IVUS, CTA enabled correct detection in 86 of 89 segments containing noncalcified plaques, 25 of 27 segments containing calcified plaques, and 118 of 131 segments without atherosclerotic plaques. Results for CTA to detect plaques were:

  • Sensitivity—97.4%
  • Specificity—90.1%
  • Positive predictive value—89.7%, and
  • Negative predictive value—97.5%.

“Our study showed excellent sensitivity and specificity for CT to detect coronary plaques, as well as a sensitivity of 96.6% to differentiate noncalcified plaque without considering degree of stenosis, representing a significantly increased accuracy compared with several previously reported studies,” said lead author Sun.

He attributed the better results to the higher spatial and temporal resolution of 64-slice CT and to the plaque analysis software.

Lipid-rich, fibrous, and calcified plaques displayed different CT densities and can be reliably differentiated, according to the study. However, because of the overlap in the range of Hounsfield units among the various plaque components, it remains difficult to determine the definite composition of individual noncalcified plaques, researchers concluded.

“Granted, improving CT detection of plaque with automated software is progress
toward understanding plaque composition and its natural history,” Sun said. “However, it is many steps away from identifying the high-risk vulnerable plaque.”

Cross-sectional view of calcified plaque in 69-year-old man obtained by CT and analyzed with plaque software. Red area indicates lipid-rich or lipid pool area (hypodensity, thin arrow) and blue area indicates fibrous area (hyperdensity). Yellow indicates calcification (thick straight arrow) in this plaque. Green indicates contrast-enhanced vessel lumen (curved arrow)